WOMEN AND RIGHTS
Interview with Rosetta Papa

Doctor, tell us about yourself, your activism, the choices that marked your personal and professional life and the fundamental role you had in women's health in Naples.
The choice to study Medicine was perhaps not a real choice. In my family they were all engineers and I felt the need, which I can't explain to you where it came from, to choose a path that would make me close to people, that would make me useful. And so my path was born. The choice to specialize in gynecology came almost by exclusion: I didn't choose psychiatry because it scared me “the power of the mind”, with all its facets, and I didn't choose “pediatrics” because seeing a child suffering would have made me absolutely incapable of a judgment, of a logical evaluation that perhaps a doctor must have in front of a patient. In my professional history two stages have been crucial. The first stop was in Turin, in 1977. I used to work at Sant'Anna, the largest hospital in Piedmont and that is where I first became acquainted with discrimination. In those years in Turin there was a certain hostility towards southerners, on the houses you found signs that said "you don't rent to southerners" and there was a head midwife who didn't call me by name but "Naples". Yet, it was a very important experience: it made me grow humanly and professionally. Many of the patients I met came from the South, when I asked where they came from, many tried to mask the accent, pretending to be a fake Piedmontese, but then it turned out that they were from Naples, or Calabria. I felt a deep empathy for those women. They lived in a city that repelled them, but they brought with them a silent force. The second crucial turning point was my return to Naples and the meeting with the consultants. I worked at the Polyclinic for a long time, until 1997 and I must say that the obstetric clinic was the one that trained me from not only a professional point of view, but also from the point of view of attitude towards an activity, a method, research and above all a rigor. I have always combined my hospital work with territorial commitment. I fought for the birth of counseling centers, for the passage of Law 194, for the right of women to decide on their own bodies. I still remember my first assignment in Miano, a neighborhood of Naples located in the northern area of the city that at the time I didn't even know where it was. The headquarters was in a street called “Cupa delle Vedove” – a symbolic, almost cinematic name. There I learned everything, I understood what the “social determinants of health” really represent, well before they became an academic concept. I have seen, touched first-hand, what it is like to live in exclusion, in poverty, in hardship. In 1981, the Miano counseling centre was a centre of excellence, not because of me, but because we all believed in it: psychologist, social worker, paediatrician, midwife. We worked in teams, motivated, present and that's where I decided to stay. When it was necessary to choose between the hospital and the area, I had no doubts: I wanted to be useful where the need does not arrive declared, but must be deciphered. The counseling center is the place where the need for health is often not even expressed, there I learned to recognize it. Between 1997 and 1998 I chose to leave the Polyclinic. Until then, fortunately, it was possible to do both jobs because the clinics worked morning and afternoon, even on Saturdays, and I was able to reconcile them with the hours of the Polyclinic because I had a token contract. Then came the moment of choice, and I chose the territory.
In your work at the clinic you also promoted moments of sharing with the women of the neighborhood, right?
Yes, in Miano we created the “women's groups”. We used to do thematic groups on childbirth, abortion, menopause and the women of the area participated and lent themselves to be filmed to document the meetings. We made videos which we then screened during the celebrations for March 8th or in the celebrations we often organized together. One of the most active was the delicatessen in front of the clinic: she prepared the sandwiches and then said "what time will we see each other tonight?". It was true sharing, it was politics, in the highest sense of the term. “The personal is political” we said a few decades ago, and it still is today even if it seems forgotten.

Doctor, activist and pioneer of local healthcare in Naples
How did you manage to reconcile this commitment with family life and two children?
Simple: without my family welfare I would never have made it. My welfare was called grandmother Maria and aunt Cenza, my mother and my aunt. If they hadn't been there, I wouldn't have been able to do any of this, or at least not with the same dedication. And here I want to tell young women: we have strength, resilience too but we are often not aware of it and that is why, despite my age, I continue to write, to speak, to insist.
What were your biggest challenges?
Many. The first, being a woman in a man's world. In the obstetric clinic at Federico II, when I arrived, I was one of the very few female residents. The women who worked there were almost all cleaning staff or paramedics but also dealing with prevention and women's health –topics seen as minor in the hierarchy of medicine – I had to struggle. Medicine is still hierarchical, hospital-centric, academic. No political figure goes to inaugurate a vaccination center, but everyone cuts ribbons to inaugurate new CT scans, yet vaccines save lives. After Covid there has been a lot of talk about strengthening the territory, but nothing has changed, the territory remains forgotten.
And today, what would you recommend to a girl who wants to follow her path?
I would tell her to do it absolutely because there is a need for women who choose gynecology, but also who know how to see the political aspect of their work. Not party, but political in the deepest sense: committing to rights, to public health, to the dignity of women. It's not enough to know how to do your job well, you need to know why you do it, you need authenticity because women only trust if they understand that you are there for them, really. What do you think about AI and its impact on health and ethics? It scares me because for example algorithms take neutrality for granted, but nothing is neutral. I've seen before how AI can trivialize even a medical relationship. You give four inputs, and it gives you slides and speeches. But then anyone can speak, even those who have never experienced suffering first-hand. And then I worry about the selections, for example in Medicine: tests are only done on general culture, mathematics, physics, but no questions about ethics, pain, life and death. We are cutting out people who may be highly motivated, but who don't know the right theorem. This is dangerous. As far as artificial intelligence is concerned there are things that are spectacular, others are worrying. For example, if I have to prepare a report I give the artificial intelligence four inputs and it also prepares the slides for me. Do you know what that means? That anyone can talk, anyone can intervene and say things without having competence and this does harm. Another aspect that worries me about artificial intelligence is its application to medical tests, for example. Until last year, the entrance tests to medicine contained exclusively questions of general culture, mathematics, physics, scientific subjects in short: there was not a single question that concerned this person's ethical attitude towards life and death, towards pain, there was no question relating to one's values, no humanistic question. This means that people who do not know a theorem but who are perhaps strongly motivated to reach the other as a person are cut off from the University. This is what happens when the selection is made by’ artificial intelligence and it is something of concern.
So who can monitor these changes?
Surely we women because we care about different parameters. Because we have experienced first-hand what it means to fight for rights and dignity and because even today, women from the suburbs –like those I met in Miano – carry the fragility of the world on their shoulders.
